Cold Aisle Containment Solutions
Most data centers utilize HVAC systems to pump pressurized air to maintain a server inlet temperature within the proper temperature range (Current ASHRAE recommendations are for inlet temperatures of 18-27 C (64.4 deg F through 80.6 deg F) and an absolute humidity/dew point range of 5.5-15C (41.9-59 Deg F). These CRAC / CRAH solutions usually provide air under raised floors but above air solutions are also available.
This design struggles because it lacks precision. The HVAC system addresses an entire room, meaning some areas receive excess cooling, while others don't receive enough. As a result, the entire infrastructure-from the fans, to pumps, to air handlers-must work harder and consume more energy in the process.
Professionals facing such problems should first evaluate their cooling architecture and determine if the capacity exists to address existing and future compute loads. If this capacity exists, the goal is to harness it-to focus the cool air precisely where it's needed. Because of the prevalence of hot aisle/cold aisle in existing data centers, one of the more practical air management strategies is cold aisle containment.
Cold Aisle Containment augments its predecessor's (hot aisle/cold aisle) arrangement by enclosing the cold aisle. The aisle then becomes a room unto itself, sealed with barriers made of metal, plastic, or plexiglass.
Hot Aisle/Cold Aisle Challenges:
Even at minor heat loads, there are challenges associated with hot aisle, cold aisle. Some of them include:
- Bypass air-"the volume of cold supply air that enters the room but does not directly enter the IT equipment"-limits the precise delivery of cold air at the server intake.
- Hot air recirculation, where exhaust heat enters the cold aisle, either over the tops of racks or through open rack spaces, ensures that the cooling infrastructure must throw colder air at the equipment to offset this mixing.
- Hot air contamination prohibits the air handlers from receiving the warmest possible exhaust air, rendering their operation less efficient.
- Hot spots may persist as a result of all of the above
Diagram of a Data Center with Bypass Air problems (mixing of hot and cold air)
- a very common cause of power loss.
As rack densities inevitably climb, the challenges above become more severe. The infrastructure struggles to deliver a sufficient volume of cool air to the equipment and to move exhaust air to the air handlers. As it's forced to deliver colder air at a greater CFM, the cooling scheme consumes more energy from the fans through the pumps, down to the chiller. And even under minimal loads, the efficiency of these systems is suspect. The premise of cold aisle containment, though simple, can improve cooling performance.
The Evolution of Cold Aisle Containment
Cold Aisle Containment started as a makeshift design using the vinyl curtains common in clean rooms and freezers. These curtains, functioning as doors and roofs between the cold aisles, proved an inexpensive way to increase efficiency and a simple, flexible retrofit for most data center environments.
As more data centers embrace the concept, some rack manufacturers are bringing their own cold aisle containment systems to market. The barriers, instead of curtains, are fabricated from steel and use polycarbonate inserts to provide a viewing window into the cold aisle.
The same rack manufacturers, in new construction or renovation projects, may promote the use of containment with In-Row air conditioners. These units, more compact, are embedded within the row of server racks, immediately capturing server exhaust air, conditioning it, and distributing it to the cold aisle.
Due to the open architecture of the data center room, hot aisle/cold aisle cannot attain complete air separation. With the cold aisle encased, the cold air, delivered from under the floor, stays where it's needed at the server intake. The roof and walls of the containment ensure that the only place this air can exit is through the rackmount equipment. The exhaust air, because of the boundaries, routes back to the air handlers only, eliminating the previous concerns of hot air contamination and hot air recirculation.
Higher Density Installations
If there's adequate capacity in the central plant, cold aisle containment can harness that capacity to support higher density cabinet installations. With mixing out of the equation, the system can focus on cooling the load instead of the entire room. As a result, data center professionals have a more predictable system-a consistent server inlet temperature, within ASHRAE ranges, unaffected by the higher server exhaust temperature.
A server cabinet manufacturer, in testing, successfully rejected 20kW per rack with its cold aisle containment system, using a server inlet temperature of 65 degrees, Delta T across the servers of 45 degrees F, and 65% perforated floor tiles. A case study at the 2008 Silicon Valley Leadership Group, entitled Air Flow Management, advocated containment as a viable high density solution but stopped short of giving a range of cooling capacities.
Air Handler Efficiency and Capacity
Efficiency strategies often discuss Delta T. The topic is especially significant with computer room air handlers for an "elevated return temperature…to the cooling unit enables better heat exchange across the cooling coil, better utilization of the cooling equipment, and overall higher efficiency" (Niemann, 2008)
Cold aisle containment, through its boundaries, ensures that server exhaust air is not unnecessarily cooled before it returns to the air handlers. By improving the heat exchange across the coils, the containment maximizes the capacity of the entire air conditioner. In an existing facility with numerous computer room air conditioners, perhaps this means installing Variable Speed Drives (VSDs) to ensure fan speed matches the load or even turning off unnecessary air conditioners.
As a result, the facility consumes less energy and the organization saves money on the smaller electric bill.
Central Plant Energy Efficiency
ASHRAE recommends server inlet temperatures between 64.4 deg F and 80.6 deg F. Chillers typically produce chilled water around 45F degrees and inlet air around 58F degrees. This disparity exists, again, because of air mixing within the data center. As inlet air and exhaust air interact, the hope is the resulting inlet temperature falls somewhere in the ASHRAE recommended range.
Through containment, a user can eliminate this uncertainty. If he desires a 68F degree inlet temperature, perhaps he can achieve it with 58 degree F water. The warmer the water, the more efficient the chiller operates.
An EYP study compares a California facility with a 45 deg F chilled water setpoint to a 55 deg F alternative. The test approximates an annual energy savings of over $388,000, based on a utility rate of $0.10/kWH. This figure is both compelling and ambiguous, for it's not practical for every data center to simply raise their chilled water temperature. A thorough analysis of the cooling scheme is needed, especially if the central plant serves a mixed use facility.
On the data center floor, cold aisle containment provides targeted cooling. This precision has many operational advantages, as we've seen. Servers are assured a consistent inlet temperature; air conditioners can achieve greater capacities; the chiller plant can become more efficient by supplying and receiving elevated water temperatures. These improvements sound great on paper, yet they also produce tangible result: a reduction in capital and/or operational expenses. Consider the following examples:
- A presentation at 2008's Data Center Energy Summit found that containment could reduce fan speed in the subject data center by 75%. Fan speed is directly proportional to fan energy consumption (Tschudi, 2008)
- A facility in the design stages, using cold aisle containment, may require less air conditioners, reducing the initial capital expenditure.
- An existing facility with thermal challenges may be able to maximize the entire cooling infrastructure through containment, instead of undertaking a long, costly renovation or construction project.
- Depending on the location, a facility may receive rebates or incentives from its utility for deploying cold aisle containment. If so, users may demonstrate a quick ROI to their management team.
The current economic climate may delay an organization's ability to build a new data center. As a result, they will demand more uptime and more computing capacity from their existing facilities, while the industry encourages conservation and sustainability. Cold Aisle Containment proves an economical way to achieve both objectives.
EYP Mission Critical Facilities. (2006, July 26). Energy Intensive Buildings Trends and Solutions: Data Centers. Retrieved February 2, 2009, from Critical Facilities Roundtable: http://www.cfroundtable.org/energy/072106/myatt.pdf
Niemann, J. (2008). Hot Aisle vs. Cold Aisle Containment. Retrieved December 23, 2008, from APC Corporate Web Site:
Tschudi, W. (26, June 2008). SVLG Data Center Summit-LBNL Air Management Project. Berkeley, CA, United States of America.
Since 1995, 42U has been a leader in providing data center efficiency services for data center and facilities managers. Our vendor and technology agnostic approach leverages our best-practice expertise in monitoring, airflow analysis, power, measurement, cooling, and best-of-breed efficiency technologies to help data center managers improve energy efficiency, reducing power consumption and subsequently lowering energy costs.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-No Derivative Works 3.0 Unported License.
42U's containment solutions support both cold-aisle and hot-aisle segregation depending on the unique requirements of your data center. 42U's engineers will help you create a cost effective containment system, tailored to your data center, which optimizes data center airflow and maximizes cooling capacity.
Starting with a detailed analysis of IT cooling needs and CRAC / CRAH capacities, 42U's engineers determine the cooling load born by each CRAC / CRAH unit, locate hot-spots and areas of over-cooling, and evaluate existing infrastructure to determine the most practical containment strategy for your data center or server room including expected return on investment. Once the proper strategy has been determined, 42U can help you ensure proper implementation to maximize the return on your investment.
When properly implemented, containment users typically realize immediate energy savings making them eligible in certain geographies for utility rebates. In addition to designing and installing your containment system, 42U can engage your energy provider to determine your rebate eligibility. Keep in mind rebates generally need pre-approval from utility companies, and it is important to engage the rebating authority at the beginning of a containment project.
Top Cold Aisle Containment Solutions
What is the best containment solution for your data center?
Our engineers can help you select the perfect containment solution for your server room.
Click here or Call 1-800-638-2638 for a free initial data center cooling project consultation.